Home > Buying Guides > Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs 2021/2022 – Buyer’s Guide

Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs 2021/2022 – Buyer’s Guide

As an Amazon Associate, we will earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We are paid commissions for purchases made through links in the post below. Thank you for using our Links.

There are many stubborn dog breeds out there, that can make training and even going on walks difficult.

We know the one. No matter how many commands are used, or the correct training is done, the dog just won’t go the way you want it to. And if there are other dogs or distractions around, it can be almost impossible. It can make you feel like a bad dog owner.

Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs

Our Top Choice

Runner Up

Best Value

But don’t worry, you aren’t alone, which is why we decided enough was enough and started the search for the best dog collars out there for those stubborn dogs.

What is The Best Collar for Stubborn Dogs?

In this article, we will provide a list of the top collars for stubborn dogs that will provide you with the control you need when you are out on a walk so you don’t have to worry about your dog walking you instead.

SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers (Our Top Choice)

Product Highlights

SportDOG provides collars mainly meant for hunting dogs. However, that doesn’t mean that they don’t work for the average dog as well.

With a 500 yard range, two types of collars for very stubborn dogs and less stubborn dogs, and a collar that works for any dog with a neck between 5 and 22 inches around, this collar can work with any level of stubbornness and focus your dog may have.

Features

  • 21 levels of stimulation with shocks, buzzes, and tones
  • Waterproof to 25 feet
  • Rechargeable battery
  • Remote can control 3 collars at once

What We Like About SportDOG

SportDOG provides options between static, tones, and vibrations so you can find what works best for your dog. It also comes with 21 settings, so you don’t have to worry about over-stimulating your dog.

As an added benefit, the remote works with up to three separate collars so you can train a few dogs at once.

What We Don’t Like About SportDOG

Unfortunately, with the company trying hard to make a remote that is easy to use even without having to look at it, they made the controller a bit too simple.

It makes it difficult to customize the settings to your needs. Also, while most collars have a pretty long range, this collar only works up to 500 yards (about 1/4 of a mile).

Pros

  • Waterproof to 25 feet
  • Is compatible with up to 3 collars
  • Quick recharge
  • East to find the right stimulation level for your dog

Cons

  • Can be difficult to customize settings
  • Short-range (500 yards)

Educator E-Collar Series (Runner Up)

Product Highlights

The Educator E-Collar is designed to humanely train and handle more stubborn dogs. It offers 100 levels of safe stimulation including a tapping sensation. It also comes with a nightlight and is waterproof.

They are designed to make sure it is difficult if not impossible to overstimulate your dog. They claim that dogs will never vocalize any of their discomforts, or show any fear toward the collar. We found this to be true from us trying it, though we didn’t turn up the collar much more than we had to.

If you care about aesthetics, both the collar and the controller come in a variety of different colors.

Features

  • Ergonomic stopwatch design
  • 100 different levels of stimulation
  • Vibration and tone options are available
  • A pavlovian tone for effective stimulation

What We Like About Educator E-Collar

There is a lot to like about this collar. From the different-sized prongs to the range the controllers still worked at. As an added bonus, some dogs can be sensitive to nickel, which a lot of dog collars use in their prongs. However, Educator has an option for dogs like that and makes a few lines with titanium.

Educator E-collars come in a variety of shapes, distances, and even colors, so you can be sure to find the right product for you from their site.

What We Don’t Like About Educator E-Collar

Unfortunately, it isn’t all perfect. The remotes tend to feel a little flimsy and easy to break. Also, the battery life isn’t great, and the whole battery needs to be replaced after about 9 months.

It is also pretty expensive. The whole set can cost you about $250 dollars. However, they do have a regular set that is about the same price as many others on this list.

Pros

  • Variety of educator E-collars for the right size and distance for you
  • 1/3 to 1-mile range
  • Can train two dogs at once
  • Lots of stimulation levels
  • Prongs for long/thick hair
  • Options available for dogs sensitive to nickel
  • Waterproof collars and remote

Cons

  • Remote feels flimsy
  • The battery needs replacing after about 9 months
  • Expensive

Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar

Product Highlights

This Dogtra collar provides dependable and durable collars and remotes, so you can be sure they work when needed. It is designed to fit any dog that has a neck 8-26 inches around.

It also comes with a dog clicker, t help you keep up your positive reinforcement training even while using the collar.

This collar is designed to work over a long distance, about 3/4 of a mile, and has over 100 different stimulation levels to make sure you find the perfect setting for your pet that will make them listen without causing harm.

Features

  • Can go up to 3/4 mile
  • 127 levels of stimulation and vibration
  • Waterproof
  • Filters out other signals for minimal electronic interference.

What We Like About Dogtra 1900S

The Dogtra 1900S comes with a lot of different stimulation levels for precise control. In fact, they provide 127 levels of stimulation and vibration settings so that you can make it a perfect setting for your dog without ever worrying about undue harm.

The quick-charge batteries are also nice, taking about 2 hours to charge them. While I usually try to keep them charged overnight, I found it was a nice feature when I had forgotten. I could charge them for a few minutes before heading out the door to make sure I had enough battery.

The easy-to-see LCD screen also allows for quick viewing of the setting and battery level, so you can check even at night.

What We Didn’t Like About Dogtra 1900S

Sometimes, we found the settings to be a little too much. While it was nice to have so many options to be sure we could find one that wouldn’t harm our dog, they sometimes seemed so similar we couldn’t tell if there was actually any difference.

The cost of the collar didn’t really seem to be worth it. Where other remotes could train two or even three dogs at once, this one was only able to do one. To go up to two dogs, there was a price cost of almost $100 more.

Pros

  • Many stimulation levels for precise control
  • Fully waterproof remote and collar
  • Quick charge batteries (2 hours)
  • Easy-to-see LCD screen shows stimulation and battery level

Cons

  • Made for one dog, the second dog costs $100 more
  • Expensive, with the basic one costing about $250
  • Might be too many settings

Garmin Delta XC Bundle

Product Highlights

The Garmin Delta XC Bundle is designed to be able to take a beating. With replaceable contact points, you can use this even if something happens to the prongs. It also works for a pretty long distance, reaching up to half a mile or longer. There are 18 levels of stimulation and you can train up to three dogs at once.

Features

  • 18 levels of stimulation, both continuous and momentary
  • Tone ad vibration options
  • Long-lasting, rechargeable remote and collar (up to 80 hours)
  • Replaceable contact points

What We Like About Garmin Delta XC

With this Garmin Collar, our favorite part was that the contact points were interchangeable. This meant that not only could we replace them if something broke, but we could change the length of the prongs. This works great for dogs with longer fur.

What We Don’t Like About Garmin Delta XC

The biggest issue with the Garmin is that it provides inconsistent stimulation. A lot of the time, when hitting the button, it would deliver a lighter shock or quieter sound than it should.

Though we were careful, this could lead to some very dangerous situations For example, if someone upped the shock setting to get their dog to listen and it decided to work at the correct level, it could cause dog harm and much more stimulation than they needed.

Pros

  • Waterproof remote
  • 1/2 to 3/4 mile range
  • Can control up to 3 collars
  • Long battery life

Cons

  • Inconsistent stimulation (sometimes shocks a lot less than its setting)
  • Poor quality service
  • Doesn’t seem to work well for large dogs

PATPET 680A D Dog Shock Collar

Product Highlights

The PATPET dog collar is designed to fit pretty much any dog with a collar that can fit anywhere between 5 and 27 inches around.

It doesn’t have as many levels of stimulation as some of the other collars we have on this list, but it still offers enough variation to get a setting that fits your dog.

Features

  • Both beep and vibration options
  • 16 levels of shock stimulation
  • About 1/2 mile range
  • Collar fits neck sizes between 5 and 27 inches

What We Like About PATPET 680A

The PATPET is a great low-income option. It is pretty reliable despite being only $50 or so. With most of the other ones costing over $100, this is a dramatic difference.

What We Don’t Like About PATPET 680A

The biggest feature that we didn’t like about this one is the fact that it can shock your pup randomly, even if you never pressed the button.

Not only is this scary, as you may not even realize how often it is going off without paying close attention, but it can also cause your dog to unlearn good habits if it shocks at the wrong times.

Pros

  • Multiple stimulation levels
  • Decent range
  • Waterproof collar
  • Made for almost any dog
  • Able to handle 2 dogs on 1 remote
  • Good price ($50)

Cons

  • Different color options have different prices
  • Sometimes, the collar will shock without you pressing the button
  • Sometimes, the collar may not work at all

MAISOIE Waterproof Dog Shock Collar with Remote

Product Highlights

The MAISOIE dog collar combines cost-saving methods with the features we are looking for.

Though it is one of the cheaper options on this list, is provides two channels for handling two dogs, a long battery life, and has an option to vibrate, tone, and shock as needed/wanted.

Features

  • Beep, vibrate, and shock training modes
  • 1/4 mile range
  • Detachable prongs for appropriate coats
  • 10 settings

What We Like About

This collar and remote set is actually very cheap compared to some of the other models. It also comes with a controller that can handle two different collars. It also comes with two carry options so you don’t have to worry about losing the remote.

What We Don’t Like About

While for the majority of us, we might not have a problem with the remote not being waterproof, it is still a bit of a bummer when the rest of the remotes are. Also, if you are going to use the collar for birding, you risk not having the remote able to handle water.

Pros

  • Long battery life with a short recharge time
  • Able to use the remote for two dogs
  • Safety lock to prevent misoperation
  • Comes with a lanyard or option to clip

Cons

  • The Remote is not waterproof
  • Only has a 1/4 mile range

SportDOG Brand YardTrainer 100S Remote Trainer

Product Highlights

If you want a dog collar that has a long charge time and has different options for getting your dog to break focus, then this one by SportDOG might be for you. It is a lot more simple than other brands, but it has everything you need for your stubborn dog.

Features

  • Waterproof up to 25 feet
  • Can vibrate, beep, or has 8 levels of shock
  • 100 and 300-yard range options
  • About 60-hour charge on both collar and remote

What We Like About

The long-lasting battery is great for forgettable people who don’t remember to change things as much as they should. It also charges quickly, so you don’t have to wait for a long time when you do forget.

What We Don’t Like About

This collar is definitely only for those who want to use it to keep their dog focused when they are stubborn. It has a short-range, just a few settings, and it only works for one dog.

Pros

  • Long, rechargeable battery life
  • Waterproof
  • Quick-charge
  • Wide range of dog sizes with 5-22 inch neck size allowable

Cons

  • Short-range
  • No warning for low battery
  • Not too many levels
  • Only for one dog

PetSafe Stubborn Dog In-Ground Pet Fence and Waterproof Reciever Collar

Product Highlights

Maybe you’re not really looking to train your dog beyond making sure it knows the boundaries of your home. Around a third of an acre in size, this fence and collar combination can be shaped whichever way you need.

Features

  • Customizable fence shape covering 1/3 acre of space
  • Tone, vibration, and shock stimulation modes with 4 levels
  • Waterproof collar
  • Works with all PetSafe fence receiver collars

What We Like About

The PetSafe In-Ground Pet Fence is great for hassle-free training when it comes to teaching your stubborn dog to stay in the yard. The waterproof collar is a must for any training collar, especially when there may be sprinklers involved.

What We Don’t Like About

While the fence produces a warning when your dog gets close to the border, there is no way to remotely correct your dog’s behavior within the yard so barking and chewing can remain an issue.

Also, because there are only four levels of stimulation, any one of those levels may be too high a level to be safe for your dog or too low for your dog to respond to.

Pros

  • Hands-free correction of yard boundaries
  • Waterproof
  • Compatible with many PetSafe products

Cons

  • Lengthy setup
  • No remote for manual training corrections
  • Limited stimulation levels

Irazia Shock Dog Train Collar with Remote

Product Highlights

If you want a collar that just does the basics and doesn’t cost you a lot of money, the Irazia training collar is a great option. It comes with 16 stimulation levels, and allows for vibration and beep options. It also allows you to train two dogs, and has about a 1000 foot range.

Features

  • 16 stimulation levels, vibrate and beep options as well
  • Two channels for training two dogs on a single remote
  • 1000ft range (about 0.2 miles)
  • Safety lock with key

What We Like About

It is a pretty cheap shock collar, only costing about $40. Despite that, it works well and has various settings to help correct your dog’s stubborn tendencies.

What We Don’t Like About

They claim that this dog collar is for large dogs between 20 and 100 pounds. However, the collar fits dogs with a neck that is 3.5 inches to 7.5 inches in diameter.

This didn’t make sense at first. Where most dog collars measure the distance around the neck, this one does the diameter, which can make it confusing if you don’t look properly.

Pros

  • Options for correction
  • Long-lasting battery
  • Affordable ($40)

Cons

  • Short-range
  • A little confusing

What to Look for When Buying a Collar for your Dog?

Collars are important. They provide a place to put a dog ID, vaccination tags, license, owner’s information, and a place to connect the leash.

However, there is an additional benefit when you own a stubborn dog. A collar can also be a way to make sure your dog actually obeys you.

Collar Size

It is important to find a collar that fits your dog properly. You don’t want a collar that is too tight or loose, or your risk injuring the dog or having them escape.

Before buying a collar, make sure you measure your dog’s neck, so you know what size you need. It is important to actually measure your dog’s neck and not their current collar, even if it fits well.

Intensity

Next, you need to determine how strong you need the intensity. If you have a dog that is so focused on something that it would run full-speed into something dangerous or harmful, it might need a medium-to-high intensity.

This is important as it stops you from over-stimulating your dog.

Distance Range

If you are simply using your collar for on walks, you probably don’t need one that has a long-range. However, if you want to use your dog for hunting, or if they are good at slipping their leash, you might want one that is designed for longer ranges.

Type

Shock collars inflict pain on a dog in order to get them to stop whatever negative behavior they are doing, These collars are often frowned upon. This is because many people tend to use them as a quick solution instead of taking the time to train their dogs properly.

However, sometimes the training just doesn’t work well, and extra help is needed. Shock collars are one option, but there are also sound and vibrate collars that are able to do the same thing, but without as much pain.

Best Collars for Stubborn Dogs FAQs

Do Shock Collars Work for Stubborn Dogs?

Shock collars are great options for stubborn dogs, but should really only be used when proper training and other options just don’t work.

What is The Difference Between SportDOG’s E-Collar and Stubborn Dog Collar?

The E-Collar is for dogs that are more sensitive to stimuli. The Stubborn Dog Collar is for those that aren’t sensitive and need a higher level of stimulation.

Why Aren’t Other Adverse Collars on This List?

Prong collars and choke collars are considered inhumane to use on dogs, and studies have shown that they lead to more aggressive behaviors than others.

Are SportDOG’s Remote and Collar Both Waterproof?

Yes, both the collar and the remote are able to handle being submerged into about 25 feet of water, so you don’t have to worry about it breaking while birding.